The House That DEI Built: Leadership Failures in Los Angeles

Los Angeles, a city once synonymous with resilience and opportunity, now finds itself at the mercy of leaders who seem to prioritize identity politics over competence. From the Mayor's office to the Fire Department, Los Angeles has become a case study in the dangers of placing diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) above merit. Recent catastrophic wildfires have laid bare the failures of this approach, revealing a city ill-prepared to face emergencies despite having an array of highly credentialed officials at the helm. So, what happened? How did things fall apart so spectacularly?

A Governor Who Missed the Flames

Let us begin with the broader context. Governor Gavin Newsom, in his characteristic pursuit of political theatrics, slashed $100 million from California’s wildfire prevention budget in June 2024. Now that wildfires have ravaged the state, Newsom’s priorities remained unshaken—not toward fixing his mistake but instead directing $50 million to combat the incoming Trump administration’s policies. This act of defiance against Washington—at the expense of Californians—foreshadowed the mismanagement that would unfold in Los Angeles.

A City’s Leadership in Crisis

At the local level, Mayor Karen Bass epitomizes the new face of DEI governance. A former physician’s assistant with a political career rooted in social justice, Bass’s focus has consistently been on equity over ability. Her administration is a microcosm of this ethos: the Los Angeles Fire Department (LAFD) is led by three chiefs, all celebrated for breaking barriers as lesbians but now infamous for presiding over a department woefully unprepared for disaster.

The three chiefs, while lauded for their historic appointments, have been criticized for their lack of operational experience. Critics argue that their focus on implementing internal DEI initiatives diverted attention from addressing critical staffing shortages and equipment failures. For example, under their tenure, the department’s emergency response times have worsened, and recruitment efforts have prioritized demographic quotas over operational skill.

At the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power (LADWP), Janisse Quiñones—appointed in May 2024—has spent more time championing DEI initiatives than ensuring there was enough water for the city's fire hydrants. Quiñones’s professional background, while rich in administrative roles, revealed little experience in managing large-scale water infrastructure. Her predecessor, Martin L. Adams, had a reputation for prioritizing operational efficiency, leaving a stark contrast in leadership styles.

The Santa Ynez Reservoir Debacle

Take, for instance, the saga of the Santa Ynez Reservoir. In February 2024, Martin L. Adams, the outgoing LADWP veteran, took the reservoir offline for repairs to meet safe drinking water standards. With his retirement looming and Quiñones’s DEI-driven agenda taking center stage, the repair bids languished. By the time the wildfires began, the reservoir remained drained, leaving the LAFD without critical water reserves.

Quiñones’s failure to prioritize operational readiness—combined with the fact that she reported directly to Mayor Karen Bass at her own misguided insistence, rather than to Deputy Mayor of Public Safety Brian K. Williams—meant that she was the only person at City Hall aware the reservoir was empty. Mayor Bass had no idea that Quiñones’s had taken the reservoir offline much less the awareness that she would need to explain why it was so vital to refill it. However, without visibility into the broader public safety framework, Quiñones failed to grasp the critical impact of the empty reservoir on firefighting efforts. Her subsequent attempts to blame power outages for low water pressure were exposed as false, adding another layer of dysfunction to the city’s leadership.

The Deputy Mayor’s Fall

Meanwhile, Brian K. Williams, arguably the most qualified member of Bass’s administration, was sidelined in a dramatic and controversial manner. Williams’s portfolio included oversight of the LAFD and other public safety agencies. Yet, his tenure unraveled as tensions grew between him and Mayor Bass over the lack of resources available to the LAFD. In November 2024, Fire Chief Kristin Crowley—famed for being Los Angeles’s first lesbian fire chief but less known for operational prowess—sent a memo warning that the department was severely understaffed and underfunded. A subsequent memo in December highlighted the devastating impact of $18 million in budget cuts would have on the LAFD's ability to fight wildfires—wildfires that would come just a month later.

Williams’s attempts to shield the LAFD from the fallout of these decisions put him at odds with Bass. After reportedly warning the Mayor that she would bear responsibility for any wildfire failures, just two weeks later Williams found himself accused of calling in a bomb threat to City Hall—a charge many view as politically motivated. No one at City Hall believes Williams was responsible for the threat, but many believe Bass had a clear motive to frame him for calling it in. On December 17, the FBI raided his home, and the next day, Bass placed him on administrative leave. Thus, the one individual capable of coordinating a response to the impending wildfire crisis was removed from his post. Bass didn't even bother to name an acting deputy before she left the country.

A Mayor Absent in Crisis

Despite promising not to travel internationally during her tenure, Bass accepted an invitation to attend Ghana’s presidential inauguration. She left for Ghana just two days after the National Weather Service warned of extreme fire conditions driven by high Santa Ana winds. Bass departed on January 4, leaving a city with no Deputy Mayor of Public Safety, a crippled fire department, and depleted water reserves.

When the Palisades Fire erupted on January 7, Bass was on the other side of the globe. The fire’s destruction was swift and merciless, decimating communities while firefighters struggled with low water pressure and insufficient manpower. By the time Bass returned on January 8, the city was in chaos. The following day, the Eaton Fire broke out, compounding the crisis.

Accountability Absent from DEI Governance

As the smoke cleared, the failures became undeniable. Chief Crowley, now without Williams' protective buffer, publicly criticized the Mayor’s lack of preparedness, highlighting the consequences of budget cuts and staff shortages. In response, Bass threatened to fire Crowley but ultimately backed down after a closed-door meeting on January 10. Speculation abounds as to what transpired during that meeting, but the result was clear: no one was held accountable.

A Tale of Two Leaders

The starkest contrast to Bass’s failures lies in the actions of her 2022 mayoral opponent, Rick Caruso. Ironically, Caruso had been highly critical of Bass and her lack of fire preparedness the year before, warning that the city was at risk of burning down. His warnings proved prophetic. Two days before Mayor Bass left for Ghana, Caruso took proactive steps to safeguard his properties from the impending wildfires. He hired private firefighters and deployed water trucks to ensure that his Palisades Village Mall would be protected. While the homes and neighborhoods surrounding his mall are now destroyed, the mall itself remains unscathed. Caruso’s actions raise an uncomfortable question: would the rest of the Palisades have been spared under his leadership?

Identity Over Merit

The collapse of Los Angeles’s leadership during this crisis is a cautionary tale about the perils of prioritizing identity over competence. From the Governor’s shortsighted budget cuts to the Mayor’s DEI-driven appointments, the city’s leadership failed at every level. The wildfires of 2025 may have been fueled by nature, but their devastation was enabled by a government that chose ideology over functionality. The prioritization of DEI over operational excellence has created a leadership vacuum where identity trumps skill, with devastating consequences for the citizens of Los Angeles.

If you don't already please follow @amuse on 𝕏 and subscribe to the Deep Dive podcast.